The Trouble With Sunshine by Yamile Saied Méndez (Scholastic Press, 272 pages, grades 4-7). Dorani has gotten in trouble (again), this time for reading a banned book at school. But when her mother suffers a fatal heart attack on the way to pick her up, Dori is wracked by guilt and grief. Forced to leave her beloved Miami friends and family to go live with her seemingly cold and uncaring aunt on a Montana ranch, Dori finds an unexpected bond with a traumatized horse named Sunshine. The two begin healing together, and in the process, Dori finds new friends, a new family, and new causes to fight for. When Dori and Sunshine have to deal with an unexpected crisis at the ranch, they are able to rise to the occasion together, cementing their bond, as well as Dori’s new connection with her aunt. Thanks to Scholastic for providing me with a free review copy.
This heartfelt story will appeal to animal lovers. Dori’s journey through her grief will resonate with many readers, who will cheer her on as she discovers family secrets that lead her to a better understanding of both her mother and her aunt. The epilogue, told in three sets of texts to Dori’s best friend in Miami, felt a little rushed, although it was nice to see most of the loose ends tied up happily.
Please Pay Attention by Jamie Sumner (Atheneum Books for Young Readers, 240 pages, grades 5-8). Although Beatrix uses a wheelchair due to cerebral palsy, she’s a confident and happy sixth-grader. But that sense of security is shattered when a school shooter invades her small Christian school, killing five people including Bea’s teacher. Afterwards, Bea is supported by her adoptive mother Max and the kind couple who share their duplex, but she still is traumatized by nightmares and a fear of indoor spaces. When Max discovers a therapeutic horseback riding program that specializes in working with kids with disabilities, Bea is surprised to find herself bonding with a horse there whose connection starts a healing process. By the end of the book, she’s able to attend the reopening of the school and begin to find a new normal for herself. Includes an author’s note in which she writes about the school shooting at Covenant School near her home in Nashville in which a close friend was killed, and how this event influenced the creation of the book.
This novel in verse explores how trauma suddenly disrupts the fabric of everyday life, leaving a world in which nothing can ever be the same again. Bea is a funny and compassionate narrator, often a bit too hard on herself, who finds healing through riding and by advocating for better gun control laws. As I often find in novels in verse, her emotional journey felt a little hurried and not as deeply explored as other formats allow, but it also felt raw, realistic, and ultimately hopeful.